You are reading

Astoria law firm represents woman seeking damages following Starbucks coffee spill

starbucks1Dec. 1, 2014 By Michael Florio

An Astoria law firm representing a woman who claimed that she was burned by a Starbucks coffee overcame a significant legal hurdle in her quest for damages last month.

Devrim Cacin-Worthy, a Flushing resident represented by Sacco & Fillas, claimed in a lawsuit filed in Federal District Court that she bought a regular cup of coffee at a Starbucks in Nassau County in Nov. 2011 and moments later the lid came off and she spilled it — causing severe burns.

In court papers, Worthy admitted she did not know the coffee’s temperature, nor did she check to see if the lid was properly affixed before picking up her drink from the server.

Starbucks filed a motion to dismiss the case to avoid the possibility of a trial. However, Starbucks did not provide sufficient evidence to contradict Worthy’s account, according to District Judge Denis Hurley.

Hurley said that there was enough evidence that “reasonably supports her claim that defendants breached a duty of reasonable care.”

Further, he added, the possibility that Worthy’s own squeezing of the cup causing the lid to come off was “sufficiently remote,” and the facts establish a “reasonable probability that her injury was caused by Starbucks.”

Tonino Sacco, a partner at Sacco & Fillas representing Worthy, said “the reasonable probability is enough to take it to trial.” Nevertheless, “it still has to be proved by a preponderance of evidence; this just allows the case to go to trial.”

Starbucks Case

email the author: news@queenspost.com

2 Comments

Click for Comments 
Anonymous

It goes without saying that when you order a non-specified ICED coffee, that your beverage will be hot…

but because common sense doesnt hold up in court as a defense, isnt this why all cups everywhere have a “caution, contents may be extremely hot” label?? ever since that woman won $10 million from mcdonalds?

Reply
Anonymous

Coffee is a HOT beverage. It’s common sense to be careful when handling it. Another one trying to make money.

Reply

Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

Queens gun buyback takes 74 firearms off streets, including ghost guns and assault weapons: DA

Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz announced Monday that 74 firearms were taken off the streets at the Greater Allen A.M.E. Cathedral of New York in Jamaica during a gun buyback event on Saturday, June 14. The weapons were exchanged for bank cards pre-loaded with cash, with no identification required and no questions asked.

“Gun buybacks serve as a critical tool for reducing gun violence and promoting public safety within our communities,” Katz said. “This Saturday, working with the NYPD and clergy leaders in Jamaica, we received 74 surrendered guns — including five automatic weapons. As a result, these firearms will not be used to cause heartache and tragedy.”

Queens Distance Runners hosts second annual track meet at St. John’s University, spotlighting Olympian and local talent

Jun. 16, 2025 By Paulina Albarracin

Dozens of runners gathered at the DaSilva Field Track in St. John’s University for the second annual track meet last month. Hosted by Queens Distance Runners (QDR), a grassroots running organization, the sporting competition welcomed sprinters and distance runners of all skill levels to test their abilities, vying for the podium in track events from 100 meters to 5,000 meters.

Western Queens lawmakers back DOT’s 31st Street bike lane redesign

June 13, 2025 By Shane O’Brien

State Senator Kristen Gonzalez, Assembly Member Jessica González-Rojas and Council Member Tiffany Cabán issued a joint statement voicing strong support for the Department of Transportation’s (DOT) proposed redesign of 31st Street in Astoria, which includes the installation of eight-foot-wide protected bike lanes beneath the elevated N/W subway tracks.

From spa retreats to public pools: Queens has a swim spot for everyone

Jun. 13, 2025 By Jessica Militello

With temperatures rising and the official start of summer just around the corner, there’s no better time to find a pool in Queens to help you beat the heat. Whether you’re looking for a relaxing spa escape, a rooftop party spot, or a free afternoon swim in your neighborhood, Queens offers a range of pool experiences for every vibe and budget.