You are reading

Simotas to Introduce Legislation to Improve “Raise the Age” Criminal Record Sealing Law

Assemblymember Aravella Simotas (Photo: Courtesy of AM Simotas)

Feb. 1, 2019 Staff Report

Assemblymember Aravella Simotas announced yesterday that she is introducing legislation to correct a shortcoming in the record sealing law enacted last year as part of New York’s Raise the Age reforms.

While the law currently allows individuals to apply to have a felony conviction sealed if a judge granted them “youthful offender” status, those who did not receive that status are left behind.

New York law has historically provided judges with the discretion at sentencing time to grant 16, 17 and 18-year-olds with “youthful offender status,” which gave them a chance to have no criminal record even for a felony.

The state, until Raise the Age was signed into law, used to automatically prosecute 16- and 17-year-olds as adults, and a judge would decide whether “youthful offender” status should apply at sentencing. The Raise the Age legislation upped the age of an adult to 18.

The Simotas bill would amend the New York State Criminal Procedure Law to allow past offenders who have stayed out of trouble for ten years, to apply for conviction sealing if they were eligible for, but did not receive youthful offender status when they were sentenced.

“Expanding eligibility for conviction sealing will give people who committed crimes in their youth the chance to become full members of society in adulthood. If someone has stayed out of trouble for 10 years, I think they should be granted the chance to move beyond the burden of a criminal record,” said Simotas said.

Simotas said she became aware of the lapse in the law after state Supreme Court Justice Joseph Zayas, the administrative judge for the criminal term in Queens Supreme Court was interviewed by the New York Law Journal about a Dec. 12, 2018 decision he issued, reluctantly denying the sealing request of a 50-year-old woman identified as Jane Doe who had been convicted of attempted second degree robbery when she was 16 years old.

Doe was eligible to receive youthful offender treatment, but did not receive it.  Doe completed her sentence of five years’ probation in 1988 and stayed out of trouble ever since. In his decision, Justice Zayas noted that he was constrained by current law and forced to deny Doe’s request to have her conviction sealed, an outcome he said was “inconsistent with the laudable goals of the sealing statute.”

email the author: news@queenspost.com

5 Comments

Click for Comments 
Saul alinsky

good when a teenager robs and shoots up a bank and kills a loved one of your what will u say then more?? Hang em high??

Reply
Butter weeda and 9 trey

good when they rob a bank and kill someone you care about karma will get you ten folds lady!

14
27
Reply
Sara Ross

I think the laws should be changed so that if somebody commits a crime and they are 12 or not much older, that their names are printed in the paper and not withheld because of their age. Old enough to commit a crime, old enough to let the world know about it. They lost their rights to privacy and no plea deals. The victims don’t get plea deals and neither should criminals.

4
21
Reply
makes sense

Yeah, why shouldn’t someone be punished forever because of a crime they commited when they were 12?

4
2
Reply
Jon

Who reads the paper anymore?

Yes, let’s bring back public shaming on minor children.

Or, realize that most likely a kid getting in trouble at 12 is either 1) doing something stupid like kids do or 2) probably has a horrible home life and needs help not shaming.

11
Reply

Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

Advocates urge passage of New York for All Act as Assembly session nears end

Jun. 16, 2025 By Jimmy Robles

As the State Senate concluded its legislative session on Thursday, immigrant rights advocates renewed calls for lawmakers to pass the New York for All Act before the Assembly adjourns on Tuesday, June 17. The proposed legislation, along with several other immigration-related bills, remains pending as the clock winds down on this year’s session.

Queens gun buyback takes 74 firearms off streets, including ghost guns and assault weapons: DA

Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz announced Monday that 74 firearms were taken off the streets at the Greater Allen A.M.E. Cathedral of New York in Jamaica during a gun buyback event on Saturday, June 14. The weapons were exchanged for bank cards pre-loaded with cash, with no identification required and no questions asked.

“Gun buybacks serve as a critical tool for reducing gun violence and promoting public safety within our communities,” Katz said. “This Saturday, working with the NYPD and clergy leaders in Jamaica, we received 74 surrendered guns — including five automatic weapons. As a result, these firearms will not be used to cause heartache and tragedy.”

Queens Distance Runners hosts second annual track meet at St. John’s University, spotlighting Olympian and local talent

Jun. 16, 2025 By Paulina Albarracin

Dozens of runners gathered at the DaSilva Field Track in St. John’s University for the second annual track meet last month. Hosted by Queens Distance Runners (QDR), a grassroots running organization, the sporting competition welcomed sprinters and distance runners of all skill levels to test their abilities, vying for the podium in track events from 100 meters to 5,000 meters.

Western Queens lawmakers back DOT’s 31st Street bike lane redesign

June 13, 2025 By Shane O’Brien

State Senator Kristen Gonzalez, Assembly Member Jessica González-Rojas and Council Member Tiffany Cabán issued a joint statement voicing strong support for the Department of Transportation’s (DOT) proposed redesign of 31st Street in Astoria, which includes the installation of eight-foot-wide protected bike lanes beneath the elevated N/W subway tracks.