Rendering of the BQX at Queens Plaza
Oct. 23, 2017 By Nathaly Pesantez
A documentary that claims the city’s proposed Brooklyn-Queens light rail connector is a road to gentrification will be screened in Astoria on Wednesday.
The short documentary, titled “Gentrification Express: Breaking Down the BQX”, will be shown at the Greater Astoria Historical Society, located at 35-20 Broadway, at 6:30 p.m on Oct. 25. The film, just over 17 minutes, was made by filmmakers Amanda Katz and Samantha Farinella, who will be in attendance and will answer questions about the film.
The documentary looks at Mayor Bill de Blasio’s plan, released February 2016, to bring a streetcar through a 16-mile stretch by the Brooklyn and Queens waterfronts. The rail system, which would go through several neighborhoods, including Astoria, Long Island City and Greenpoint, and all the way down to Sunset Park, is seen by the filmmakers as a dishonest attempt to alleviate the city’s overburdened transit system. They say the BQX just serves the interests of the real estate industry.
“What’s so gross about this project [BQX] is the way it’s being sold,” Katz, a 26-year-old graduate student at Hunter College, said. Katz said the “slick” advertisement and promotion of the BQX as a job stimulator and a boon for low income residents, among other outcomes, were the impetus to begin to research and read between the lines of the proposal.
Proposed route
The film includes the opinions of urban planners and local activists, who claim that the developers steadily building along the BQX’s planned route have donated money to de Blasio. Concerns of actual construction costs of the project, currently estimated at $2.5 billion, are also addressed in the film, with Samuel Stein, a Hunter College Urban Studies professor, noting that the cost has been low-balled to deflect opposition. Once the plans are green-lighted costs then rise.
The BQX’s “value capture” funding model is also criticized, where increases in property taxes along the streetcar’s path will be used to pay for the rail system. The filmmakers argue that this hike will drive some longtime residents out as their housing costs go up.
“I don’t know how de Blasio wouldn’t have thought through the outcomes,” Katz said.
The film does not feature representatives from the Friends of the BQX, the Economic Development Corporation, or de Blasio’s office. Katz said the EDC gave an introductory phone interview when the film was proposed in August 2016, but the agency eventually stopped responding.
Katz and Farinella are currently promoting the film, released August 2017, and are reaching out to local community groups to discuss the project. The Oct. 25 screening is being hosted by the Queens Anti-Gentrification project, and will also feature a screening of “Flushing Meadows Corona Park: What it’s Worth” by Queens Creative Solidarity. Queens Neighborhood United, the Coalition to Defend Corona, the Justice for All Coalition, and the Long Island City Coalition will also be in attendance. Free food and refreshments will be available at the event, which will run until 8:30 p.m.
The BQX is still in its infant stages, where groups like Friends of the BQX are holding introductory meetings in communities along the proposed route and receiving feedback from local residents. In an Oct. 18 town hall in Brooklyn, de Blasio announced that the project would likely break ground in 2020.
Featured Events
10 Comments
There should be a connection between Brooklyn and queens, but I don’t think this is it.
I fully support this documentary.
The project would be more logical if it were extended to Laguardia Airport in Astoria. That way people can easily get to and from the airport. They should make it run through the park and onto 20th Ave until it reaches the airport.
We need a train to Brooklyn. If not this we need something to get to Brooklyn.
Its not fast enough to connect truly Astoria to Williamsburg, etc but it will do a lot to connect sections of neighborhoods to each other that were previously inconvenient.
I love it. I’ll ride back n forth all day
NO WE DO NOT – MORE MONEY IN THE POLITICANS POCKETS
This isn’t light rail, it is a trolley that will have to stop at every red light – pretty much just big buses. You’ll be hard pressed to find a more ridiculous idea.
It is meant to price out the small industrial firms along the route so that more mega housing can be built.
Give me a break. The BQX will be a godsend to all those people who live west of 21st street. I have to wonder if these two young filmmakers have ever had to take a bus to a subway to get to work. At 6am. Or, have they ever had to haul young children anywhere into Manhattan from that area. What about people with less mobility? The BQX will be a great service for them, and allow far better connections that the labyrinthine bus routes. And what about those people in Brooklyn? Same deal. The BQX will allow people who live in those areas, in Queens and in Brooklyn, often lower income areas, to have better access to Manhattan. Plus, it will be a new “cross town” route — heck of a lot easier to get to parts of Brooklyn from here. Ever tried to get to Red Hook from Astoria by MTA? It’s hell. My only concern is how long it will take to built this thing.
The light rail will be terrible, especially in the winter when it snows. It is political. We really don’t need it.