You are reading

East Elmhurst Man Expected to get 6 months Jail for Stealing Tortoise: DA

Millenium (sic) with member of the 111 Precinct

Dec. 8, 2017 By Tara Law

An East Elmhurst man pleaded guilty yesterday to stealing a 95-pound tortoise from a Queens environmental center in July, according to the Queens District Attorney’s office.

The 17-year-old African-spurred tortoise named Millenium (sic) disappeared from Alley Pond Environmental Center in Douglaston and was found in Connecticut a week later.

Shawn Waters, 37, pleaded guilty Thursday to fifth degree criminal possession of stolen property.

Queens Criminal Court Judge Gia Morris indicated that she would sentence Waters to six months in jail on Jan. 16, according to prosecutors.

Environmental center staffers realized that the tortoise, valued at about $2,500, was missing at around 4 p.m on July 16, according to the charges. Staffers then discovered a hole at the rear fence by the tortoise habitat.

The investigation uncovered that a Stamford, Conn. man had placed an ad on Craigslist offering to sell a musk turtle. A day later, he received a phone call from a man who offered to trade an African Spurred tortoise for the musk turtle.

The Connecticut man met the caller on July 23 at the Metro North train station in Fairfield. He gave the man the turtle and $300 in exchange for the tortoise.

Soon after, the Connecticut man learned through news reports that Millenium had gone missing. He turned the tortoise in to the NYPD on July 24. A staff member from the environmental center identified the tortoise and brought it home.

The police traced the phone call between the two men to Waters. Waters allegedly confessed to a NYPD detective that he had arranged the trade for the turtle

email the author: news@queenspost.com
No comments yet

Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

Catch the fall vibe at these western Queens breweries

Sep. 3, 2025 By Jessica Militello

September rings in the start of Oktoberfest from mid-September through October, featuring special brews, fun events and more fall fun. Western Queens is filled with breweries to enjoy seasonal brews, fall flavors and the start of cooler weather as Autumn approaches, making it a perfect time to meet up with friends at these local spaces.

Op-Ed | Four years after Hurricane Ida, Queens deserves real climate resilience

Sep. 2, 2025 By Assembly Member Jessica González-Rojas

Four years ago, Hurricane Ida tore through our neighborhoods of East Elmhurst, Corona and Jackson Heights, leaving behind devastation we will never forget. We lost neighbors to the floodwaters. Families saw their homes destroyed, their basements wiped out, their lives upended. Immigrant families—so many of them undocumented—were hit the hardest, often excluded from relief altogether. Ida was not just a storm; it was a wake-up call.